Former LaSalle Police Officer Erik Hernandez Sentenced to Prison in the Manslaughter of Juston Reffel

Former LaSalle Police Officer Erik Hernandez was sentenced to six years in the Colorado Department of Corrections after pleading guilty to manslaughter for shooting and killing 38-year-old Juston Reffel outside a Family Dollar store in LaSalle, Colorado.The sentence was handed down on April 25, 2025, by Weld County District Court Judge Marcello Kopcow, according to the Weld County District Attorney’s Office. Prosecutors said Hernandez shot Reffel on May 3, 2023, while responding to a report of what a citizen believed was a suspicious vehicle at the Family Dollar store.Hernandez was originally indicted by a Weld County statutory grand jury on one count of second-degree murder in June 2023. According to CBS Colorado, the indictment accused Hernandez of shooting Reffel as Reffel was trying to drive away from the store. CBS reported that Reffel was struck in the torso, citing the indictment and autopsy report.The case did not end with a murder conviction. In November 2024, a Weld County jury could not reach a unanimous verdict after nearly two days of deliberations. Hernandez later accepted a plea agreement and pleaded guilty in January 2025 to manslaughter, a class 4 felony.

Body-camera reporting added more detail to the encounter. Police1, citing 9News reporting, said Hernandez was on his third day of field training when he and his training officer approached the vehicle in the Family Dollar parking lot. The officers reportedly went inside the store looking for the driver before Reffel ran out, got into the vehicle, reversed several feet, and began to drive away.

According to Denver7, Hernandez fired four shots as Reffel left the parking space, hitting him in the torso. Reffel later died at the hospital.

After sentencing, Weld County Deputy District Attorney Lacy Wells said, “There’s nothing more serious than the loss of human life,” and added that Hernandez would never again be a police officer. “Juston deserved better and so did the citizens of Weld County,” Wells said, according to the district attorney’s office.

The case stands as another example of how a suspicious-vehicle call escalated into a fatal police shooting, followed by a murder indictment, a hung jury, a manslaughter plea, and a prison sentence.

Sources:
Weld County District Attorney’s Office
CBS Colorado: Former officer sentenced
CBS Colorado: Grand jury indictment
Denver7
Police1

Edited/composite image for commentary or AI-generated satirical image. Not a photograph,
not evidence of a real event, and not documentary evidence unless stated otherwise.
Scroll to Top